Architectural Shingles vs. Stone Coated Steel Shingles: Things to Consider

When it comes to selecting roofing materials, homeowners are often faced with many choices. Two popular options are Architectural Shingles and Stone Coated Steel Shingles. Each type has its unique features, benefits, and advantages. In this article, we will explore the characteristics of both architectural shingles and stone-coated steel shingles. We will discuss their advantages and disadvantages and hopefully help you make an informed decision for your roofing needs.


Architectural Shingles: Aesthetic Appeal and Durability

Architectural shingles, also known as laminated or 3 dimensional shingles, have become increasingly popular for their enhanced visual appeal and durability. These shingles are crafted with multiple layers of asphalt, providing a three-dimensional look that mimics the appearance of natural materials like wood or slate. These have become very popular with neewly constructed homes.

One of the key benefits of architectural shingles is their longevity. These shingles typically have a longer lifespan compared to traditional 3-tab shingles. The added thickness and weight are the reasons for the notable durability of these shingles. These shingles are thus more resistant to harsh weather conditions, including strong winds and hail.

Architectural shingles are available in a wide range of styles and colors, allowing homeowners to customize their roofs to their liking. The variety in design, coupled with the longevity and durability, makes architectural shingles an attractive option for those looking to invest in a roof that combines functionality with great curb appeal.

Despite their many advantages, architectural shingles do have some downsides. One notable consideration is the cost. While they are more affordable than some premium roofing materials, architectural shingles tend to be a bit pricier than traditional 3-tab shingles. However, the long-term benefits and enhanced aesthetic value often make the increase financial commitment worth every penny.


Stone Coated Steel Shingles: Durability Meets Curb Appeal

Stone coated steel shingles represent a unique fusion of durability and visual appeal. These shingles are crafted from a galvanized steel core, providing exceptional strength, and are coated with stone chips to mimic the appearance of traditional roofing materials such as slate or wood shakes.

The primary advantage of stone coated steel shingles also lies in their durability. Steel is inherently resistant to weathering, corrosion, and other environmental conditions, making it an ideal material for roofing. The addition of stone coating enhances the shingles’ resilience, ensuring they can withstand extreme weather conditions, including heavy snows and intense sun exposure.

Another crucial factor to consider is the longevity of stone coated steel shingles. With a lifespan exceeding that of many other roofing materials, these shingles offer a long-term solution that requires minimal maintenance. Often, a newly installed roof with stone coated steel shingles, will outlive the owner of the home.

When it comes to cost, stone coated steel roofing is a higher upfront investment compared to traditional asphalt shingles. However, the long-term savings on maintenance and replacement costs certainly justifies the initial expense. Homeowners should consider their budget, the architectural style of their home, and the amount of time they plan on living in their home. No sense in spending the extra money if you plan on moving in a year or two.


Comparative Analysis

To make the decision a bit easier for you, let’s compare the key aspects of architectural shingles and stone coated steel shingles:

Aesthetic Appeal:

Architectural Shingles: Wide variety of styles and colors, which will mimic the appearance of natural materials.
Stone Coated Steel Shingles: Emulates the look of slate or wood shakes, providing a beautiful and timeless aesthetic.


Architectural Shingles: Improved durability compared to 3-tab shingles. Excellent resistant to harsh weather conditions.
Stone Coated Steel Shingles: Exceptional durability, resistant to weathering, corrosion, and other environmental factors.


Architectural Shingles: Longer lifespan than traditional 3-tab shingles.
Stone Coated Steel Shingles: Extended lifespan, requiring minimal maintenance. These shingles will last a lifetime.

Architectural Shingles: Moderately priced, with a higher upfront cost compared to 3-tab shingles. Call RoofWorx of Wentzville for accurate, up to date pricing.
Stone Coated Steel Shingles: Higher initial investment, but potential long-term savings on maintenance and replacement costs far outweigh the cost.



In conclusion, the choice between architectural shingles and stone coated steel shingles depends on various factors, most notably budget, aesthetic preferences, and long-term goals. Architectural shingles offer a visually appealing and durable roofing solution at a moderate cost, while stone coated steel shingles provide unparalleled strength and durability. Stone coated steel shingles do come with a steeper price tag.

Before making a decision, homeowners should carefully assess their priorities and consult with roofing professionals, such as the roofing experts at RoofWorx of Wentzville to determine the best fit for their specific needs. Whether opting for the classic charm of architectural shingles or the robust elegance of stone coated steel roofing, investing in a high-quality roof ensures long-lasting protection and enhances the overall appeal and value of your home.  Either way, these are both excellent choices when it comes to residential roofing.

Leave a Comment